{
  "publisher": "Sage",
  "date": "2026-10-19",
  "method": "Two fixed synthetic inputs, fresh conversations where available, first outputs, signed-out public browser tools. Sage uses a production-prompt API harness rather than these browser interfaces; settings are not controlled across products. Qualitative observations only, no universal ranking or independent validation.",
  "rubric": ["Distinguishes observed events from motives", "Addresses the seeker's own contribution when relevant", "Offers a specific next question or action", "Does not treat one-sided claims as proof", "Provides a requested message draft"],
  "observations": [
    {
      "tool": "Mei",
      "url": "https://www.textmei.com/relationship-ai",
      "case": "relationship-assumption",
      "access": "Signed out; public embedded Relationship Chat; no payment or account creation",
      "input": "My partner replied much later than usual twice this week. I think they are losing interest. Separate what I know from what I am assuming, and help me ask about it.",
      "output": "Fact: they replied much later than usual twice this week.\n\nAssumptions: that means they're losing interest — other possibilities are busyness, stress, phone/notification issues, or avoiding a topic.\n\nAsk: \"I've noticed you've been slower to reply lately — are you okay, or is something changed between us?\"\n\nHow long together?",
      "notes": "Separates observation and assumption, offers multiple explanations and a direct question. The proposed question contains awkward wording ('is something changed'). Does not establish whether any explanation is true. No assessment of repeated reliability."
    },
    {
      "tool": "Mei",
      "url": "https://www.textmei.com/relationship-ai",
      "case": "relationship-message",
      "access": "Signed out; Relationship Chat reset through its Refresh control before this input",
      "input": "We argued about money yesterday. I said “you never think ahead,” and they stopped talking. Help me write a calmer opening that owns my part without dropping the issue.",
      "output": "Hey — I’m sorry I said “you never think ahead” yesterday; that was unfair and I should’ve said my worry without blaming you. I still want us to fix the money stuff so it doesn’t keep blowing up — can we sit down tonight and agree on one small step (like a weekly check-in or one shared rule) to try? Want a shorter text version?",
      "notes": "Provides a direct draft, owns the accusation and keeps a next step on the money concern. It proposes a time and shared rule without knowing the parties' availability or finances; those are suggestions to adapt."
    },
    {
      "tool": "DeepAI",
      "url": "https://deepai.org/chat/relationships",
      "case": "relationship-assumption",
      "access": "Signed out; AI Relationship Coach preset; visible Standard mode; underlying model not established",
      "input": "My partner replied much later than usual twice this week. I think they are losing interest. Separate what I know from what I am assuming, and help me ask about it.",
      "output": "What you know: Your partner replied later than usual on two occasions this week.\n\nWhat you’re assuming: That the delays mean they’re losing interest. That’s possible, but the delays alone don’t establish why—they could have been busy, distracted, or dealing with something else.\n\nYou could ask in a calm, curious way:\n\n“Hey, I noticed we’ve been texting less promptly than usual a couple of times this week. I may be reading into it, but I’ve felt a little unsure. Is anything going on, or has something changed for you?”\n\nThen give them room to answer. Try to focus on the pattern and your feelings rather than treating the delay as proof.",
      "notes": "Clearly separates observation from interpretation, offers alternative explanations and an opening question. The interpretation is not independently verified. A sponsored module also appeared; sponsored material is excluded from this response record."
    },
    {
      "tool": "DeepAI",
      "url": "https://deepai.org/chat/relationships",
      "case": "relationship-message",
      "access": "Signed out; fresh preset opened in a new tab after the New Chat link did not visibly clear the prior conversation; Standard mode",
      "input": "We argued about money yesterday. I said “you never think ahead,” and they stopped talking. Help me write a calmer opening that owns my part without dropping the issue.",
      "output": "“Can we talk about yesterday? I’m sorry I said, ‘You never think ahead’—that was hurtful and unfairly broad. I was worried about our finances, and I still want us to make a plan together. Could we talk about what’s worrying each of us and agree on one next step?”",
      "notes": "A compact draft owns the broad accusation, preserves the financial concern and asks for a shared next step. It assumes worry about shared finances, which is plausible but was not explicitly stated. Sponsored material appeared separately and is excluded."
    },
    {
      "tool": "ChatVisor",
      "url": "https://www.chatvisor.ai/tools/ai-relationship-advisor",
      "case": "relationship-assumption",
      "access": "Signed out; landing submission routed to /chat/communication-helper and assigned a temporary guest identity automatically; no registered account was created",
      "input": "My partner replied much later than usual twice this week. I think they are losing interest. Separate what I know from what I am assuming, and help me ask about it.",
      "error": "Something went wrong, please try again",
      "notes": "First attempt returned an error. It was not regenerated. This is a technical/access observation; it provides no response-quality evidence."
    },
    {
      "tool": "ChatVisor",
      "url": "https://www.chatvisor.ai/tools/ai-relationship-advisor",
      "case": "relationship-message",
      "access": "Signed-out guest session; Start New Chat opened a fresh general Chat Advisor, so this was not a verified dedicated relationship mode",
      "input": "We argued about money yesterday. I said “you never think ahead,” and they stopped talking. Help me write a calmer opening that owns my part without dropping the issue.",
      "outputExcerpt": "Here's what likely happened: when you said that, they heard \"you're careless\" or \"you're irresponsible,\" not \"I'm worried about our finances.\" They got defensive, so talking stopped.\n\n\"I want to come back to what we talked about yesterday. I handled it badly—I came at you like it was your fault, and that shut things down. The truth is, I'm worried. I need us to think together about this, and I don't know how to bring it up without it turning into a fight. Can we try again?\"",
      "notes": "Exact excerpts from a longer answer. It offered a draft owning the speaker's approach and invited another conversation. It also inferred what the other person heard and felt, and later said the speaker felt alone; those were not established by the input. The tool/mode routing differed from the landing label."
    }
  ]
}
